Can an Executor Administer an Estate Without Probate in Victoria?

What an Executor Is

An executor is the person named in a Will who steps into the shoes of the deceased for the purpose of administering the estate. The role is part trustee, part agent and part book-keeper. In broad terms, an executor must locate and secure the deceased's assets, pay funeral expenses, debts and tax, and then distribute what remains to the beneficiaries named in the Will.

Executors owe fiduciary duties to the beneficiaries — duties of loyalty, prudence and even-handedness. Those duties begin from the date of death, not from the date of any grant of probate. An executor who delays unreasonably, mixes estate funds with their own, or distributes the wrong assets to the wrong people can be sued personally, regardless of whether they ever applied for probate.

How an Executor Obtains Authority

In Victoria, an executor's authority comes from the Will itself. The grant of probate does not create the authority; it confirms it. From the moment of death, the executor is technically in charge of the estate. The problem is practical: nobody else can see the Will, and third parties have no way of knowing whether the document you are showing them is the last valid Will or whether you are really the executor it names.

That is why institutions ask for probate. The sealed grant from the Supreme Court of Victoria does two things:

• It confirms that the Will is the last valid Will of the deceased; and
• It confirms that the person named in the grant is the executor entitled to act.

Where the institution accepts that risk on the strength of the Will and death certificate alone, probate is unnecessary for that asset. Where it does not, a grant must be obtained.

Authority Under a Will vs a Grant of Probate

Many executors are surprised that a Will, on its own, is often enough to deal with smaller estates. A bank holding a modest term deposit may release the funds on receipt of:

• a certified copy of the Will;
• the original death certificate;
• identification of the executor; and
• a signed indemnity from the executor.

The indemnity is critical. It is the bank's protection against having to pay the money a second time if a later Will turns up. The executor — and sometimes the beneficiaries — accept the risk personally so the institution does not have to.

When Probate Is Commonly Required

In practice, a grant of probate will almost always be required where the estate includes any of the following:

• Real estate held solely in the deceased's name or as a tenant in common. Land Use Victoria will not register a transfer out of a deceased proprietor's name without a grant.
• Bank accounts or term deposits above each bank's threshold, commonly between $20,000 and $50,000.
• Listed shareholdings above the registry threshold, typically between about $15,000 and $50,000 per holding.
• Aged-care refundable accommodation deposits, which providers usually release only against a grant.
• Superannuation paid to the legal personal representative rather than directly to a nominated beneficiary.
• Estates expected to be the subject of litigation, including a possible family provision claim under Part IV of the Administration and Probate Act 1958 (Vic).

When Probate May Not Be Required

Conversely, there are estates that can be administered entirely without a grant. These are usually estates made up of one or more of the following:

• Jointly owned assets. A home, bank account or investment held as joint tenants passes automatically to the surviving owner by survivorship. It is not part of the estate at all.
• Assets with designated beneficiaries. Superannuation paid under a valid binding nomination and life insurance paid outside super flow directly to the nominated person and bypass the estate.
• Modest cash balances. Where every bank balance sits below the relevant release threshold, banks will typically pay out against a Will, death certificate and indemnity.
• Personal effects and motor vehicles. These can usually be dealt with informally, although a vehicle registration transfer will still require some documentary evidence of the deceased's death and the executor's role.

Small Estates

"Small estates" is a deliberately fuzzy concept. There is no statutory definition in Victoria, but the term is commonly used to describe estates worth less than around $50,000 where no real estate is involved. In a small estate, an executor may be able to:

• collect modest bank balances against an indemnity;
• sell or distribute personal items, motor vehicles and household contents informally;
• receive any final tax refund directly from the Australian Taxation Office on production of the Will and death certificate; and
• close low-value share or managed fund holdings under the registry's small-estate procedure.

Even for these estates, careful documentation is essential. A signed inventory, copies of every payment, and written consents from each beneficiary should be kept on file.

Jointly Owned Assets

Joint tenancy is the single most important reason probate can sometimes be avoided. Real estate, bank accounts and investments held as joint tenants pass automatically to the surviving owner outside the estate. To deal with a jointly owned property after one owner dies, the surviving owner simply lodges a survivorship application at Land Use Victoria with a death certificate. The Will plays no role at all.

By contrast, property held as tenants in common does form part of the deceased's estate, and the deceased's share cannot be dealt with without a grant of probate. Understanding which form of ownership applies is often the single most important early step in any estate.

Assets With Designated Beneficiaries

Superannuation and life insurance are not automatically controlled by the Will. Where the deceased made a valid binding death benefit nomination to a dependant, the superannuation fund pays that person directly. Probate is unnecessary for that benefit. Where no binding nomination existed, the trustee has discretion, and the benefit is often paid to the legal personal representative — which generally requires a grant.

Risks of Administering Without Probate

Executors who choose to administer an estate without probate should be aware of several practical risks.

• Later Wills. Probate involves advertising the application on the Court's online notice service. That notice gives anyone with a competing claim — or a later Will — the opportunity to come forward. Without that step, an executor relying on the Will alone may not learn of a later document until after the assets have been distributed.
• Personal liability to beneficiaries. An executor who distributes the wrong shares to the wrong people can be ordered to top up the estate from their own funds.
• Personal liability to creditors. Where a creditor turns up after distribution, the executor may be personally liable to pay the debt.
• Family provision claims. Eligible persons have six months from the grant of probate to bring a claim. Distributing too early — including before any probate is taken out — exposes the executor.
• Taxation difficulties. The ATO will often insist on a grant before discussing the deceased's affairs or releasing a final refund. See our companion guide on the ATO's probate requirements for deceased estates.

Liability of Executors

The fiduciary duties of an executor are owed to the beneficiaries collectively. An executor who acts honestly, takes proper advice and follows it is generally protected. An executor who acts on instinct, distributes early, or ignores the entitlements of an estranged family member can find themselves the defendant in a Supreme Court proceeding years after the estate appeared to be wound up.

Practical examples include:

• Example 1. An executor distributes a $400,000 share portfolio nine weeks after the funeral, without applying for probate. A child of the deceased from an earlier relationship learns of the death and brings a family provision claim. The executor has to recover the shares — now worth $310,000 in a falling market — from beneficiaries who have already spent part of the proceeds. The shortfall comes out of the executor's pocket.
• Example 2. An executor releases a $35,000 term deposit on the strength of the Will and a bank indemnity. Two months later a creditor produces a personal guarantee signed by the deceased for a business debt of $40,000. The executor, having already paid the funds to the sole beneficiary, must recover them or meet the debt personally.

Why Institutions Sometimes Insist on Probate

Even where the law does not strictly require it, an institution can — and often will — insist on probate. Banks, super funds and share registries are not in the business of verifying Wills. Their policies are written to protect them from paying out twice. Common triggers include:

• any balance above the institution's internal threshold;
• any sign of family disagreement or competing claims;
• older Wills or Wills with unusual provisions;
• blended families or estranged children;
• executors who are not residents of Australia; and
• accounts that have been dormant or where the deceased was under a power of attorney before death.

Arguing with an institution's internal policy is rarely productive. In most cases it is faster — and safer — to apply for the grant.

When Legal Advice Should Be Obtained

Most executors benefit from at least an early consultation with an estates lawyer, even if they ultimately decide the estate can be administered without a grant. A short conversation will usually identify:

• which assets will and will not require probate;
• whether any beneficiary is likely to make a family provision claim;
• whether the deceased's tax affairs require any particular attention;
• the appropriate sequence of steps to protect the executor personally; and
• when distributions can safely be made, and to whom.

Our team regularly acts for executors of estates large and small. We can advise whether probate is needed, prepare and file the application if it is, and guide the executor through the full administration. We work closely with the family's accountant on any tax issues and, where necessary, with our estate litigation team when a claim is brought against the estate.

Related Reading

• Probate & Estate Administration
• Wills & Estate Planning
• Contested Wills & Family Provision Claims

Frequently Asked Questions